• Our Constitution
  • Join us
  • Contact us
مجلة مواطن
  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Support independent press
  • العربية
No Result
View All Result
مواطن
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinions

The destruction of the judicial institution in Saudi Arabia

Dr. Abdullah Alaoudh by Dr. Abdullah Alaoudh
4 September , 2021
in Opinions
A A
0
The destruction of the judicial institution in Saudi Arabia

لم يكن القضاء في السعودية مستقلًا أبدًا في أي عصر، ولكن منذ مجيء ولي العهد الحالي، دمّر بشكل ممنهج ومستمر ومقصود ما تبقى من أي ورقة تستر عورة القضاء أو تلم شتاته، وتلك النوافذ والهوامش التي كانت محلًّا للاجتهاد القضائي أو مجالًا للاستقلال في المستقبل عمل على تفكيكها وتفتيتها، وتشريد ما بقي من منها.

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedinShare on WhatsappShare on Email
  • العربية

In Saudi Arabia, the judiciary has never been independent in any era. However, since the arrival of the current Crown Prince, he has systematically, continuously and intentionally destroyed what remains of any paper that covers the faults of the judiciary or covers its dispersal. These windows and margins, which have been the subject of judicial jurisprudence or a future space for independence, have been dismantled and fragmented and the remainder have been displaced.

In Saudi Arabia, judges who were legally trained for decades relied on informal mechanisms that gave them relative independence and influence despite some ideological issues.

You can say what you want about these informal historical mechanisms, but they were instrumental in making the Saudi courts’ position linked to the judiciary and not outside of it. This relative autonomy was largely the product of traditional methods of education, qualification and integration (such as workshops) and practical training, which created an opportunity for jurisprudence and judicial discretion. Training and education have come together to give judges a strong sense of belonging to a collective identity.

Successive Saudi rulers showed great respect and caution in dealing with it. They often saw the legitimacy of the judiciary as very important to the legitimacy of the regime and the survival of the image of independence among people, despite significant breaches in the political and civic aspects.

Of course, not all tools were entirely informal. The judicial system had a codified legal basis. In 1926, King Abdulaziz Al Saud issued a decree providing for the Hanbali School of thought (the dominant doctrine in Najd) to be the official tradition to be applied in Saudi courts. In general, the Hanbalis, and a large number of Islamic scholars trained in classical doctrines, usually resist comprehensive institutionalisation.

The reason is that scholars have traditionally suggested that this might pave the way for the dominance of the State (or other external powers) over jurisprudence and religion.

Over the years, the Saudi state has strengthened its work on formalisation in ways that have gradually reduced the role of the judiciary. Recently, with the current Crown Prince, the pace of diminishing judicial power has accelerated through the use of three main tools:

  • The first was to rely on royal and government decrees and decisions for fundamental legal issues. Decrees and resolutions are codified legislation that result in reducing the space for traditional independent thinking known as ijtihad, which judges were practicing. Recently, the torrent of intermittent edicts has become a constant flow. Some judges fear that it will soon become a flood, as some have told me. 
  • The second was the establishment of specialised courts and quasi-judicial agencies based entirely on governmental decrees and official procedural directives that gradually demolished the jurisdiction of the general courts. These agencies have become so vast that a judge in the general courts has called it a “shadow judiciary.” Many judges have noted that taxes, insurance and bank affairs became under the responsibility of quasi – judicial commissions. These committees now became the pillars in their area of competence and their opinions can no longer be appealed to the general courts. As for judges in the General Courts, this change means that “shadow justice” is completely out of the spotlight.
  • The third tool- which in my opinion is the the most dangerous element of the equation – is the greater exercise of the executive authority over the judicial sector and its direct involvement in judicial action. In addition to its direct orders for court presidents and their representatives through the Ministry of Justice and the executive authorities to sentence some and acquit others abruptly.

In 2012, Minister of Justice, Mohamed Al-Issa, became the first to hold the highest judicial position, as Head of the Supreme Judicial Council, without abandoning his ministerial portfolio. While the Minister and his supporters considered it necessary to speed up the implementation of legal and judicial reforms, some judges expressed their dismay on the conflict of interest arising from the fact that Issa is obtaining two positions at the same time.

Judges also objected to his use of his powerful authority to manage various matters of judicial affairs down to the smallest details, and and considered his behaviour to be burdensome.

One of the most important aspects of the judicial intervention is the series of executions and the politicised sentences of activists, intellectuals, academics and scientists in exchange for the acquittal of the country’s political, administrative and financial corrupts and those involved in well-known international crimes recognised by many concerned authorities, such as in the case of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, may he rest in peace. 

For all that, I can clearly say that the judicial institution in Saudi Arabia is being completely destroyed and tampered with in a crude and direct manner.

Tags: authoritarianismen-sliderJudiciarySaudi Arabia
ShareTweetShareSendSend
Dr. Abdullah Alaoudh

Dr. Abdullah Alaoudh

Writer from Saudi Arabia

Read more اقرأ أيضاً

Humanitarian crisis in Gaza represents a major tragedy and health challenge
Opinions

Humanitarian crisis in Gaza represents a major tragedy and health challenge

13 November , 2023
توسعت الأبحاث التي تربط بين مسألة انعدام الجنسية والنزوح القسري بشكل كبير في السنوات الأخيرة؛ ففي العام 2014، أثبتت دراسة محدودة
Opinions

Between Inequality and Legal Discrimination: The Risks of Statelessness on Syrian Children

5 March , 2023
لننظر مثلًا لوضع الرجل الكويتي الذي يجنس أبناءه فور ولادتهم وفي أي بقاع  ، والقادر كذلك على تقديم طلب منح الجنسية لزوجته،
Opinions

The Pierced Flasks

5 March , 2023
بهذا السؤال يلاقيني العديد من المعنيين/ات بالقضية؛ هل يوجد أمل في الحصول على الجنسية؟ أم أن هذا مستحيل؟ محملين بأثقال من الإحباطات التي عاشوها
Opinions

“Is there any Hope?” … No, there is Action! “

5 March , 2023
في ظل هذه المعطيات، كان من البديهي جدا عندما تقرر "مواطن" أن تطلق مشروعها الجديد "مجلة مناصرة" أن تكون موضوعة عددها الأول أحد أهم قضايا المرأة
Opinions

“Munasara” Magazine is a culmination and consolidation of years of documenting and analyzing human rights issues in “Muwatin”

5 March , 2023
فالدليل واضح على أن المجتمعات التي تدعم المواطنة المتساوية للرجل والمرأة، وتعزز الاندماج، هي التي تحمل في طياتها أكبر قدر من الأمل لتحقيق
Opinions

Towards Full Citizenship

5 March , 2023

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All rights reserved to Muwatin Media Network ©

Website Designed by Muwatin Digital Creative Agency

Muwatin Media Network

Beyond Red Lines

United Kingdom – London

Contact us: contact@muwatin.net

Executive Director and Editor-in-Chief:

Mohammed Al Fazari

mkalfazari@muwatin.net

<
2023
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
▼
>
Jan27 Posts
Feb28 Posts
Mar63 Posts
Apr26 Posts
May27 Posts
Jun24 Posts
Jul21 Posts
Aug20 Posts
Sep22 Posts
Oct27 Posts
Nov24 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan30 Posts
Feb22 Posts
Mar21 Posts
Apr19 Posts
May13 Posts
Jun14 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug26 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct22 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec26 Posts
Jan18 Posts
Feb8 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr22 Posts
May25 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul14 Posts
Aug23 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov16 Posts
Dec17 Posts
Jan16 Posts
Feb24 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr32 Posts
May12 Posts
Jun30 Posts
Jul31 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec20 Posts
Jan4 Posts
Feb2 Posts
Mar19 Posts
Apr12 Posts
May28 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul26 Posts
Aug9 Posts
Sep29 Posts
Oct23 Posts
Nov9 Posts
Dec30 Posts
Jan22 Posts
Feb1 Post
Mar18 Posts
Apr13 Posts
May15 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug7 Posts
Sep14 Posts
Oct4 Posts
Nov14 Posts
Dec15 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May17 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul11 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep10 Posts
Oct16 Posts
Nov22 Posts
Dec24 Posts
Jan2 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun0 Posts
Jul0 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep0 Posts
Oct0 Posts
Nov0 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan12 Posts
Feb12 Posts
Mar8 Posts
Apr16 Posts
May11 Posts
Jun16 Posts
Jul2 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep2 Posts
Oct13 Posts
Nov13 Posts
Dec10 Posts
Jan3 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar12 Posts
Apr5 Posts
May3 Posts
Jun9 Posts
Jul9 Posts
Aug11 Posts
Sep7 Posts
Oct10 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec14 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun7 Posts
Jul4 Posts
Aug6 Posts
Sep5 Posts
Oct5 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec6 Posts

Get Muwatin updates sent to your email

  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Support independent press
  • العربية
Menu
  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Support independent press
  • العربية

Muwatin Media Network

Beyond the Red Lines

United Kingdom – London

Contact us:

contact_en@muwatin.net

Executive Director and Editor-in-Chief:

Mohammed Al Fazari

mkalfazari@muwatin.net

<
2023
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
▼
>
Jan27 Posts
Feb28 Posts
Mar63 Posts
Apr26 Posts
May27 Posts
Jun24 Posts
Jul21 Posts
Aug20 Posts
Sep22 Posts
Oct27 Posts
Nov24 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan30 Posts
Feb22 Posts
Mar21 Posts
Apr19 Posts
May13 Posts
Jun14 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug26 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct22 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec26 Posts
Jan18 Posts
Feb8 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr22 Posts
May25 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul14 Posts
Aug23 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov16 Posts
Dec17 Posts
Jan16 Posts
Feb24 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr32 Posts
May12 Posts
Jun30 Posts
Jul31 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec20 Posts
Jan4 Posts
Feb2 Posts
Mar19 Posts
Apr12 Posts
May28 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul26 Posts
Aug9 Posts
Sep29 Posts
Oct23 Posts
Nov9 Posts
Dec30 Posts
Jan22 Posts
Feb1 Post
Mar18 Posts
Apr13 Posts
May15 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug7 Posts
Sep14 Posts
Oct4 Posts
Nov14 Posts
Dec15 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May17 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul11 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep10 Posts
Oct16 Posts
Nov22 Posts
Dec24 Posts
Jan2 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun0 Posts
Jul0 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep0 Posts
Oct0 Posts
Nov0 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan12 Posts
Feb12 Posts
Mar8 Posts
Apr16 Posts
May11 Posts
Jun16 Posts
Jul2 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep2 Posts
Oct13 Posts
Nov13 Posts
Dec10 Posts
Jan3 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar12 Posts
Apr5 Posts
May3 Posts
Jun9 Posts
Jul9 Posts
Aug11 Posts
Sep7 Posts
Oct10 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec14 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun7 Posts
Jul4 Posts
Aug6 Posts
Sep5 Posts
Oct5 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec6 Posts

لتصلك نشرة مواطن إلى بريدك الإلكتروني

Get Muwatin updates sent to your email

تابعوا قناة مواطن على يوتيوب
اشترك

All rights reserved to Muwatin Media Network ©

Website Designed by Muwatin Digital Creative Agency
  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Support independent press
  • العربية
Menu
  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Support independent press
  • العربية
  • Stories
  • Opinions
  • Dialogues
  • Our Network
    • Conferences
    • Munasara Magazine
  • Our Constitution
  • Join us
  • Contact us
  • العربية
  • Support independent press

All rights reserved to Muwatin Media Network ©

Receive our monthly newsletter

To receive our updates on WhatsApp click here, then send (subscribe)

Subscribe

  • Asset 1

All rights reserved to Muwatin Media Network©

Website Designed by
MDC Agency.

Muwatin Media Network

Beyond the Red Lines

United Kingdom – London

Contact us: contact_en@muwatin.net

CEO and Editor-in-Chief
Mohammed Al-Fazari
mkalfazari@muwatin.net

<
2023
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
▼
>
Jan27 Posts
Feb28 Posts
Mar63 Posts
Apr26 Posts
May27 Posts
Jun24 Posts
Jul21 Posts
Aug20 Posts
Sep22 Posts
Oct27 Posts
Nov24 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan30 Posts
Feb22 Posts
Mar21 Posts
Apr19 Posts
May13 Posts
Jun14 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug26 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct22 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec26 Posts
Jan18 Posts
Feb8 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr22 Posts
May25 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul14 Posts
Aug23 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov16 Posts
Dec17 Posts
Jan16 Posts
Feb24 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr32 Posts
May12 Posts
Jun30 Posts
Jul31 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec20 Posts
Jan4 Posts
Feb2 Posts
Mar19 Posts
Apr12 Posts
May28 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul26 Posts
Aug9 Posts
Sep29 Posts
Oct23 Posts
Nov9 Posts
Dec30 Posts
Jan22 Posts
Feb1 Post
Mar18 Posts
Apr13 Posts
May15 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug7 Posts
Sep14 Posts
Oct4 Posts
Nov14 Posts
Dec15 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May17 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul11 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep10 Posts
Oct16 Posts
Nov22 Posts
Dec24 Posts
Jan2 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun0 Posts
Jul0 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep0 Posts
Oct0 Posts
Nov0 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan12 Posts
Feb12 Posts
Mar8 Posts
Apr16 Posts
May11 Posts
Jun16 Posts
Jul2 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep2 Posts
Oct13 Posts
Nov13 Posts
Dec10 Posts
Jan3 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar12 Posts
Apr5 Posts
May3 Posts
Jun9 Posts
Jul9 Posts
Aug11 Posts
Sep7 Posts
Oct10 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec14 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun7 Posts
Jul4 Posts
Aug6 Posts
Sep5 Posts
Oct5 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec6 Posts

Receive our monthly newsletter

  • Website Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
Menu
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

  • Asset 1

Muwatin Media Network

Beyond the Red Lines

United Kingdom – London

Contact us: contact_en@muwatin.net

CEO and Editor-in-Chief
Mohammed Al-Fazari
mkalfazari@muwatin.net

<
2023
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
▼
>
Jan27 Posts
Feb28 Posts
Mar63 Posts
Apr26 Posts
May27 Posts
Jun24 Posts
Jul21 Posts
Aug20 Posts
Sep22 Posts
Oct27 Posts
Nov24 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan30 Posts
Feb22 Posts
Mar21 Posts
Apr19 Posts
May13 Posts
Jun14 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug26 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct22 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec26 Posts
Jan18 Posts
Feb8 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr22 Posts
May25 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul14 Posts
Aug23 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov16 Posts
Dec17 Posts
Jan16 Posts
Feb24 Posts
Mar23 Posts
Apr32 Posts
May12 Posts
Jun30 Posts
Jul31 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep24 Posts
Oct20 Posts
Nov29 Posts
Dec20 Posts
Jan4 Posts
Feb2 Posts
Mar19 Posts
Apr12 Posts
May28 Posts
Jun22 Posts
Jul26 Posts
Aug9 Posts
Sep29 Posts
Oct23 Posts
Nov9 Posts
Dec30 Posts
Jan22 Posts
Feb1 Post
Mar18 Posts
Apr13 Posts
May15 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul20 Posts
Aug7 Posts
Sep14 Posts
Oct4 Posts
Nov14 Posts
Dec15 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May17 Posts
Jun11 Posts
Jul11 Posts
Aug15 Posts
Sep10 Posts
Oct16 Posts
Nov22 Posts
Dec24 Posts
Jan2 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun0 Posts
Jul0 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep0 Posts
Oct0 Posts
Nov0 Posts
Dec0 Posts
Jan12 Posts
Feb12 Posts
Mar8 Posts
Apr16 Posts
May11 Posts
Jun16 Posts
Jul2 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep2 Posts
Oct13 Posts
Nov13 Posts
Dec10 Posts
Jan3 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar12 Posts
Apr5 Posts
May3 Posts
Jun9 Posts
Jul9 Posts
Aug11 Posts
Sep7 Posts
Oct10 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec14 Posts
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun7 Posts
Jul4 Posts
Aug6 Posts
Sep5 Posts
Oct5 Posts
Nov7 Posts
Dec6 Posts

لتصلك نشرة مواطن إلى بريدك الإلكتروني

Receive our monthly newsletter

تابعوا قناة مواطن على يوتيوب
اشترك

All rights reserved to Muwatin Media Network©

Website Designed by
MDC Agency
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
Menu
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy